Liverpool’s clash against Brighton at Anfield this Saturday produced plenty of talking points: a 2–0 victory, superb team dynamics, and tactical dominance. But amid the post-match analysis, one name has captured the imagination of pundits, fans, and even opposition coaches — Federico Chiesa.
Even Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher, who rarely minces words, was left in awe of the winger’s performance. Speaking live after the match, Carragher did not hold back:
“From now henceforth, HE Federico Chiesa should be starting games for us. I don’t care who Arne Slot benches for him, but he must be in the starting lineup.”
This emphatic endorsement speaks volumes about Chiesa’s impact in the short time he was on the pitch. With limited minutes, he delivered a performance so comprehensive that it left pundits questioning why he hadn’t already been a regular starter under Slot.
Chiesa’s performance: A masterclass in efficiency
Despite restricted playing time, Chiesa demonstrated all the qualities that define a world-class winger and forward:
1. Total pitch presence
Carragher highlighted how Chiesa was “everywhere” on the pitch. From pressing high in Brighton’s defensive third to dropping back to help midfield transitions, he covered ground with purpose and intelligence.
2. Tactical awareness
Chiesa consistently positioned himself to exploit Brighton’s weaknesses, making himself available for passes, stretching the defensive line, and creating pockets of space for teammates.
3. Direct impact on attack
Although he did not score, Chiesa’s movements and link-up play facilitated both of Liverpool’s goals. Analysts noted that the buildup to the second goal was heavily influenced by Chiesa’s clever positioning and combination play.
4. Defensive contribution
Slot’s system relies heavily on forwards pressing from the front, and Chiesa excelled here too. He repeatedly forced turnovers and disrupted Brighton’s attempts to build from the back, showing that his defensive work rate matches his attacking prowess.
Carragher’s endorsement: What it means
Jamie Carragher’s comments carry significant weight in the footballing world. He is widely respected for his insights and does not make sweeping recommendations lightly. By calling for Chiesa to be an automatic starter, Carragher is signaling that the winger’s quality is undeniable and too valuable to remain on the bench.
This also puts Arne Slot under pressure. With Liverpool chasing consistency and supremacy in the Premier League, starting Chiesa regularly could be the key to unlocking their attacking fluidity and depth.
Liverpool fans react
The reaction from supporters has been instant and overwhelmingly positive. On social media, many fans described Chiesa’s cameo as “transformative,” noting that he brought energy, vision, and unpredictability that the squad has been missing.
Several supporters even compared him to past Liverpool greats who could influence a game in limited minutes — a testament to how impactful his performance was.
Brighton’s perspective
Chiesa’s influence was not unnoticed by Brighton either. Fabian Hürzeler, Brighton’s coach, admitted post-match that he was repeatedly frustrated by Liverpool’s winger, acknowledging the difficulty of marking him during his short spell on the pitch.
“We tried everything to contain him, but he constantly pulled defenders out of position. He made our plans difficult to execute,” Hürzeler said.
Even the opposition recognized the threat Chiesa posed, reinforcing why Carragher’s call for a starting role is fully justified.
Tactical implications for Arne Slot
Slot now faces a managerial dilemma. His current setup favors established starters, but Chiesa’s performance demonstrates a game-changing ability. Analysts suggest that integrating Chiesa more consistently could:
Increase Liverpool’s attacking unpredictability
Provide more depth on the wings for pressing and counter-attacks
Enhance goal creation opportunities, particularly against organized defenses
Given Carragher’s endorsement and the tangible impact on the pitch, it seems only a matter of time before Chiesa is locked into the starting XI.
Conclusion: A must-start for Liverpool
Federico Chiesa’s brief but electrifying performance against Brighton has ignited a wave of praise from pundits, fans, and even former players. Jamie Carragher’s demand for him to be a guaranteed starter underscores the belief that he is ready to consistently influence matches at the highest level.
Liverpool have a decision to make. With the Premier League title race intensifying, there is little room for hesitation. Chiesa has proven that impact, quality, and intelligence cannot be confined to limited minutes — he deserves the stage, every week